Casting Allusions


  • Jason Holt Acadia University



aesthetic value, casting, allusion


The modest philosophical literature on allusion focuses on descriptive issues concerning literary examples, and thus tends to neglect both allusions in other media and normative concerns about allusions in general. In this paper I will help fill both gaps through an analysis of three different cases of what I call casting allusions, which depend on the audience’s recognition that a certain cast member was also in the cast of a different work. These cases vary greatly in aesthetic merit, and this is best explained via two dimensions of allusive value: richness (given the medium) and dynamic engagement. All else being equal, an allusion will be more aesthetically pleasing when it relies on a wider variety of medium-relevant channels or prompts less passive, more evolving audience response. Such an account finds further support in elaborate cinematic examples, such as the tapestry of allusions to Bruce Lee in the Kill Bill films.


Carroll, Noël. 1998. Interpreting the Moving Image. Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press.

Hermerén, Göran. 1992. “Allusions and Intentions.” In Intention and Interpretation, edited by Gary Iseminger, 203–220. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

Holt, Jason. 2006. “A Darker Shade: Realism in Neo-Noir.” In The Philosophy

of Film Noir, edited by Mark T. Conard, 23–40. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky.

— 2015. “Ex Ante Allusions.” Aesthetic Investigations 1:14–22.

Irwin, William. 2001. “What Is an Allusion?” Journal of Aesthetics and Art

Criticism 59:287–297.

— 2002. “The Aesthetics of Allusion.” Journal of Value Inquiry 36:521–532.

Leddy, Michael. 1992. “Limits of Allusion.” British Journal of Aesthetics


Perri, Carmela. 1978. “On Alluding.” Poetics 7:298–307.

Ross, Stephanie. 1981. “Art and Allusion.” Journal of Aesthetics and Art

Criticism 40:59–70.

Wollheim, Richard. 1980. Art and Its Objects, Second Edition. Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press.